Help Deciding

[Chip Valecek]

@Naters-Calderone I really like your style, however for the prompt I prefer your old man and baby concept more. But if it was me, I would take all of these ideas to finish. They are all great.

[Jiří Kůs]

I like the last one most

[Naters.Art]

@Chip-Valecek yeah, for concept, that's my favorite one too. but it's not very dynamic. they look for skill over "cleverness"

[MOO]

I love the one with the policeman and the box of spilled donuts and oozey leg. It made me laugh

[amberwingart]

I really like the policeman one - that one's really creative & you got an awesome angle on it! Really interesting angles appear to be one of your strengths!

[Naters.Art]

@Marsha-Kay-Ottum-Owen thanks. laughter is always my goal

[Lee White]

@Naters-Calderone not sure I agree with that one. Concept will always be #1 and execution will be secondary to that.

[Naters.Art]

@Lee-White good to know...that makes the decision harder though

[Naters.Art]

I played around with the lighting on this one too, which is very similar to the lighting in the cop image...but it just doesn't have slime... I haven't worked on the old mans background yet, but i wanted to check with you all to see if i should continue with it or do you still think i should go with the monster pic? also, please let me know what I could improve upon in either.

[Chip Valecek]

@Naters-Calderone I still like this one best, i would have him looking down at the baby vs out into the distance.