Poe Cover Late Crits Welcome Revised x3

[Charlie Eve Ryan]

I did not have this ready for today, but wanted to share it here for feedback.

[mattramsey]

Like the high color contrast. You may want to tweak the bird a bit--it's looking more dove/pigeon like than raven like (as I see it--others may see differently).

Do the white lines on the hill represent something? They are a cool element but maybe instead of just lines they could be some other type of form that would reference his stores

[Charlie Eve Ryan]

Hi Matt, thanks...I think you are right the beak is too short. I'll work on that!

[seanwelty]

@Charlie-Eve-Ryan Are you the one that posted the red riding hood image. I recognize the brush and have the same feeling that the texture gets to be a bit mechanical and repetitive? If you are going for a natural media look it sort of breaks the illusion. Be careful to add a bit more variety in the textures.

[Lydia M]

I dig the heart pupil concept, the contrast and the texture! The raven looks a little dazed and lovestruck though with the heart in his eye and his head tilted skyward. I don't know Poe very well but my impression has always been he was a melancholy fellow. The raven came to him when he was in deep grief and didn't bring any hope, so maybe if you flipped it so he's coming in from the top and looking down? It would read more like oppressive and suffocating grief (which is exactly what you want in art, right?! Ha!)

[Charlie Eve Ryan]

@seanwelty Thanks Sean, I'll add some variety in the feathers.

[Charlie Eve Ryan]

@gimmehummus Thanks for the feedback, I'll test that out and see if it feels more dramatic.

[Charlie Eve Ryan]

Here is a revised version...

[Charlie Eve Ryan]

Here is one with a quick border on it, since it is getting a bit lost against the white site page.

[Suzy Heitz]

I love your aesthetic. This piece is evolving nicely too. Did you consider putting the elements on a toned gray background instead of the stark white? Even the shade of red could be more ominous. Perhaps with some of your texture and shadow. Poe is so dark and this piece is somewhat bright. The other think that I noticed first was the direction of the tears. It's right in your first iteration, but now that the bird is facing down, the direction of flow would change also. Consider what makes sense and ignore the rest.

[Charlie Eve Ryan]

Thanks Suzy. Testing out a darker background and added some splatter.

[Charlie Eve Ryan]

I pulled back a bit on the gray on the bottom to let some of the white through.

[Thrace]

@Charlie-Eve-Ryan These are awesome! I think I like the second one with a little white coming through. Its too bad you didn't have a chance to enter!

[Lydia M]

With his head angled down he looks more hopeless. Nice! I looked at the negative space in his neck and it made me think of a hill so what about this....?

[Charlie Eve Ryan]

@Thrace-Shirley-Mears Thank you! I'll do next month for sure, I had a few things going on so I didn't enter this time. It was a fun one to work on though.

[Charlie Eve Ryan]

@gimmehummus Oh nice! Good eye, that is pretty sweet looking!