Hey Looking for a Critique on this WIP

[Jon Anderson]

The main thing that jumps out to me would be having your pirate overlap the island a bit to really help push the distance. As you have it now you are giving us clues that the island is distant with the water overlapping the island, the blurriness, and lacking detail yet at the same time it feels like it is on the same 2D plane as the pirate. Making the pirate overlap the island will help sell those other cues that he's almost able to rest but he still has a small journey to get there. I hope that helps.

[TessaW]

Hi Jason. Great start! I am a little unclear about your intentions with the environment and atmosphere. I have some suggestions, which will depend on what you are trying to achieve.

So far, what I'm getting most from this scene, is that it's a smoky day from a fire. Perhaps his ship burned down? It looks like the sun is being masked by the smoke, but you can still see a bit of clear blue sky behind the island.

Is this your intention?

[Jason Bowen]

@tessaw Hey not exactly. I was going for a misty look which masks the island from a distance. But I was thinking to myself that I could create more interesting clouds but until I read your thoughts I forgot about that idea. Thanks I will think about what to do...

[NizhoniWolf]

Personally, I would have planned out the illustration to have more space available for the words. @Jon-Anderson mentioned moving the pirate over so he over laps the island a bit (to create more depth perception) but i also feel this would free up some natural space for those words

[Jason Bowen]

@jon-anderson Thanks for your idea. I was planning it out as a double page spread and I am a little unsure whether you should ignore the fold of the page or not... I will have to play a bit with the positions.

[TessaW]

@jason-bowen Ah, I see. In that case, I think you've gone a bit too gray and dark for the mist. What time of day is this? Do you mind if I attempt a paint over?

[Jon Anderson]

@jason-bowen If your goal is a two page spread I would leave the pirate so that he isn't broken up and add something relevant on the right side to still overlap and help with depth. Making the island wider may help with that too and would not interfere with the page break so long as you have enough of it showing on the left side that it isn't awkward looking. You just definitely don't want to put your focal point right at the page break.

[Jason Bowen]

@tessaw go for it

[Jason Bowen]

@tessaw I didn't have a time of day really. Was just thinking light haha

[Jason Bowen]

@nizhoniwolf thanks, the words are a problem I need to solve

[Jason Bowen]

I had a brain wave and drained the water a bit to give me space at the top I'm still working on the mist I need some time away from this picture haha

[TessaW]

Ok, I did a rough paint-over. I personally felt your values could be grouped a bit different so that your pirate could stand out better. I also incorporated other's suggestions. The saturation levels are my personal preference, and I think a more muted palette would work as well!

Anyway, just my thoughts.

[Jason Bowen]

@tessaw Thanks a lot for the quick paint over! It has given me some great ideas I will post my progress

[Jason Bowen]

I have done some more playing with this painting I am going to move on to the next page and see if I can create a book out of this.