@Qi In fact, I am struggling with style, but I don't think that's why I posted the article. If anything, I like too many styles, and yes, I take too long to finish a piece! But aside from that, I mostly think it's interesting how the medium and the working conditions influence the resulting images.
@robgale You make a good point. In music there are many genres, but within those genres there are fairly strict limitations and the creativity comes within them. I'm sure someone has tried crossing Irish fiddle with rap (to name two genres with fairly strict conventions), but I'm not sure the result would be recognizable! Maybe "flat style" is one genre of illustration, and there are several acceptable ones, but with so many style choices available, there is a certain homogenizing tendency within each genre in order to flourish within it. Does that make sense? In fact, when I look at the NY Times, yes, there is a lot of the flat style, but there are also others. It's more in straight graphic design that there are strict trends.
@NelsonYiap I like line a lot too, and painterly strokes. I think we have to just do what we do and find a market for it, and it's probably not either all compromise nor all stubborn individualism, but a natural mixture. In fact, the SVS guys have talked before about the danger of working too much towards a specific market. You may get hired for it and then find yourself having gone out of style! If you follow your own temperament, at least that style can mutate honestly.
@deborah-Haagenson I don't know of a specific course that would help with a tree vs. a figure, but if you follow the curriculum, you develop your skills across the board and it can't help but develop a consistent style eventually, because you have more visual vocabulary and choices.
Do you have to transition to a more cartoonish style? I think I have a little, but much less than many people, because I come from a portraiture background and I love figure drawing. I struggle more with concepts, backgrounds and style issues instead. And no, the anatomy in my figures is by no means perfect, especially as I start to exaggerate for gesture, but I find such beauty in individual people that I want some of the particulars to remain. Maybe you feel the same?